International surgeons contest Dutch euthanasia of babies with spina bifida
Saturday, January 26th, 2008From Radio Netherlands Worldwide:
Pediatric neurosurgeons from 12 countries, writing in an article in the medical journal “Child’s Nervous System,” have expressed concern over the practice in the Netherlands of actively carrying out euthanasia on babies with spina bifida.
Speaking for the Dutch Pediatric Association, Edward Verhagan rejected the international criticism, arguing that treatment should not be given to infants unless there is some hope of improvement as a result of the treatment.
The current debate was touched off by Dutch pediatric neurosurgeon Rob de Jong, writing in the same journal. De Jong surveyed medical cases and found a number in which physicians dismissed patients as having no hope, only to find later that their initial diagnoses were incorrect. In one such case, a South African child with spina bifida was denied treatment, and years later was found to be alive and leading a “reasonably independent” life. “There is no reason whatsoever for active life-termination of these newborns,” he wrote. (more…)


