Says VCU students twisted his meaning; VCU stands by its story

Recordings of Marshall’s remarks posted on the Web

From the Richmond Times-Dispatch, Washington Post, WTKR Norfolk, Virginia Commonwealth University, AP/[Newport News] Daily Press:

Virginia Del. Bob Marshall turned aside calls for his resignation Wednesday and attempted to distance himself from recorded remarks that have been construed as saying that a woman who has an abortion runs the risk of birth defects in later pregnancies as a punishment from God.

Addressing his colleagues in the Virginia General Assembly, Marshall called for a correction from journalism students at the Virginia Commonwealth University School of Mass Communications. Jeff South, an associate professor of journalism who oversees the school’s Capital News Service, said VCU stands by its report “as a fair and accurate account of the press conference that Del. Marshall held last Thursday.”

The school’s website and Marshall’s website both carried recordings and transcripts of Marshall’s remarks, delivered last week at a press conference organized against public funding for Planned Parenthood.

(more…)

‘Our leaders fail the neediest’

Columnist Rick Green, writing in the Hartford Courant, says Connecticut’s leaders have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on a legal fight to keep the Southbury Training School open, even though they know the facility violates federal discrimination law. “We will pay dearly for this,” he writes. A legal challenge to the sprawling institution for people with intellectual disabilities is being heard in federal court.

Green describes Southbury as a “1950s-era model for segregated care of the disabled,” and a “world that I thought existed only in film documentaries.” He says former Connecticut Gov. John Rowland caved to pressure from fearful families and staff fifteen years ago in a “transparent political move” that effectively halted efforts to move institutional residents back into the community and would “infect state policies for years to come.”

Experts say there is no reason why people with complex disabilities can’t live satisfying lives in the community with appropriate support, but families and guardians need to be educated about the possibilities to allay fears. Further, they say, community-based care comes at a lesser cost: approximately $122,000 per person per year, as compared with Southbury’s pricetag of $350,000 each for some 450 residents. An excerpt:

After more than a decade of waiting, we await a solution from a federal judge.

That’s what you get when nobody leads.

See also: School for intellectually disabled under pressure to change — Hartford Courant

From the Washington Post, [Norfolk] Virginian-Pilot:

As detractors organized an online petition calling for his resignation, Republican Virginia state delegate Bob Marshall apologized for public remarks suggesting that women who have abortions risk having children with disabilities as a punishment from God.

“The number of children who are born subsequent to a first abortion who have handicaps has increased dramatically,” Marshall said last week at a news conference calling for an end to state funding for Planned Parenthood. “Why? Because when you abort the firstborn of any, nature takes its vengeance on the subsequent children.”

“In the Old Testament, the firstborn of every being, animal and man, was dedicated to the Lord,” he added. “There’s a special punishment Christians would suggest …”

In a statement on his website, Marshall said he regretted his “poorly chosen words.”

He said his broader point was that published medical research suggests abortion raises the risk of miscarriage and birth defects in subsequent pregnancies, and that those findings echo the Bible’s teaching that abortion is wrong.

“I’m saying look at the medical journals,” said Marshall, who produced two studies to buttress his contention. “That’s not saying ‘Bob Marshall thinks a Down syndrome baby is a punishment.’ “

UPDATE: Press release from The Arc: Arc of VA families outraged by elected official’s remark

Lennard Davis, writing at Huffingtonpost.com about the flap over “Family Guy,” says Sarah Palin misrepresented the show’s meaning in an effort to “attack the left in any form.” Far from being a slight on people with disabilities, Davis said, the episode “serves to show us that we can’t and shouldn’t underestimate people with Down syndrome.” An excerpt:

Tellingly, she didn’t mind Rush Limbaugh use the R-word, saying is was just “satire.” Satire? What is Family Guy? Greek tragedy?

The moral of this story isn’t that Family Guy is an insensitive show; it’s that Palin is using Trig as a hostage to shield her from the shoot-out of the last election. With Trig in tow she’s not the incompetent former governor of Alaska or the incendiary anti-wonk, she is simply the good Mom protecting her child and all people with disabilities.

If Palin really cared about people with disabilities, she would be supporting health care legislation and stronger enforcement of the Americans with Disabilities Act. But then that would be more of that “hopey changey” stuff she ridicules.

Lennard Davis is professor of English, disability studies, and medical education at the University of Illinois at Chicago.

(Photo from www.lennarddavis.com)

From NBC Washington and Gainesville [Va.] Times,  with audio from Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU):

Virginia state delegate Bob Marshall told a gathering in Richmond last week that children with disabilities are a punishment from God to women who have aborted their first pregnancy. The remarks prompted a wave of criticism, and Marshall later said they had been taken out of context.

“The number of children who are born subsequent to a first abortion with handicaps has increased dramatically. Why? Because when you abort the first born of any, nature takes its vengeance on the subsequent children,” said Marshall, a Republican.

“In the Old Testament, the first born of every being, animal and man, was dedicated to the Lord. There’s a special punishment Christians would suggest.”

Marshall was addressing a press conference at the state capitol called by opponents of Planned Parenthood. They urged Virginia lawmakers to stop allocating funds to the organization because it provides abortions.

“Family Guy” actress Andrea Fay Friedman is interviewed on ABC Good Morning America about her dustup with Sarah Palin.

“Sarah Palin didn’t even get the joke,” Friedman told ABC News.”It would be nice if she did have a sense of humor … Come on Sarah, laugh a little.”

The actress’s mother, Marjorie Friedman, says the “Family Guy” episode was inspirational to other people with Down syndrome because it portrayed them as “everyday teens.”

“She was feisty, she was aggressive, she was mean. It was a real acting job.”

On CNN, talk show host Leslie Marshall says the “Family Guy” controversy has been a “win-win” for both Sarah Palin and Seth MacFarlane, the show’s producer, because it “ups her popularity and the show’s popularity.” Entertainment reporter Tanika Ray says MacFarlane’s goal is to stir up controversy. “He thinks: if Sarah Palin’s responding, he did his job.”

Blogging at the Baltimore Sun, critic David Zurawik says he supports the free speech rights of Bill Maher and Seth MacFarlane, but thinks they are “bullying” people with disabilities.

…there is a larger point to these two remarks this week: I think they are emblematic of how toxic and nasty our public discourse has become.

Reading some of the comments in reaction to my post from people who found the “Family Guy” joke funny, I was struck by just how far we have fallen as a society in our anger and need to feel superior to someone else.

Chicago Sun-Times columnist Richard Roeper says Sarah Palin needs to acknowledge that the “Family Guy” episode was satire — unlike Rush Limbaugh’s “retard” reference.

And there’s coverage of Andrea Fay Friedman’s response to Palin at the New York Daily News, USA Today, CBS, Village Voice and elsewhere.