Debate rages over use of the word ‘retard’ in ‘Tropic Thunder’
August 15th, 2008
(Photo from Hartford Courant)
Lots more about the continuing “Tropic Thunder” controversy. We’ll be following it throughout the day. Let’s start here.
Stiller defends “Thunder” on the CBS Early Show. With video. Stiller says the movie is a comedy, and that people should view it in context and lighten up. (Note: Robert Downey Jr. also appeared on ABC Good Morning America, but didn’t discuss the controversy over the word “retard.” He says the filmmakers made a conscious effort to avoid offending people with racial humor involving his character, which he played in blackface.)
I appeared yesterday on The Morning Show with Mike and Juliet, a national Fox network program, along with David Tolleson, executive director of the National Down Syndrome Congress; Eddie Barbanell, one of the stars of “The Ringer,” and Gitesh Pandya of Boxofficeguru.com. David, Eddie and I talked about why the disability community views the word ‘retard’ as hurtful. Gitesh said that protests add to the film’s appeal at the box office. Eddie’s comments definitely provided the high point of the segment. With video.
Eddie also appeared with Tim Shriver on Fox & Friends. (With video.) An excerpt from Shriver’s remarks:
We’re not questioning Ben Stiller’s intent. We’re questioning and challenging the content. We don’t know what he was thinking when he was writing. We didn’t have people on the set. Nobody invited people with intellectual disabilities to screen the film in the early days. Nobody asked us to see whether this movie crossed the line. They did ask other groups. They did not ask for the voice of people with special needs.
Film critics stand firm against ‘Tropic Thunder’ protests by advocates for the disabled in the Los Angeles Times. In a wrapup of reviews from 11 media outlets, John Horn notes: “Quite a few film critics appear to be agreeing with the studios and the filmmaker, not the protesters.” Includes excerpts from reviews in Salon.com, the San Francisco Chronicle, Washington Post, New York Times, Baltimore Sun, Los Angeles Times, MTV and elsewhere.
Disabilities just aren’t funny, an op-ed by Jim Flanigan in the Albany [NY] Times Union. The executive director of the Rensselaer Arc says the movie is a “turkey” and urges people to stay home. An excerpt:
The people responsible for “Tropic Thunder” claim that they were equally offensive to many groups. The movie does make fun of actors, egotistical producers, farts, agents, war movies filled with explosions and drug dealers, all of which could be considered fair game. By adding people with disabilities to this mix, Stiller, Dream Works and Paramount are sending a not too subtle message to their young audience that they, too, are fair game.
Funny or offensive? Blackface, ‘retard’ jokes may shoot down ‘Tropic Thunder‘ — Q&A with Slate.com reviewer Dana Stevens on washingtonpost.com
Also:
Protesters speak out against ‘Tropic Thunder’ film – Hartford Courant blog
‘R-Word’ sets off protests — Chicago Tribune
Letters:
- The R-word isn’t funny — Let’s give it a rest –in the Tallahassee Democrat
- Slurs are unacceptable — in the New Orleans Times-Picayune



August 15th, 2008 at 10:33 am
Here’s some good news - from Defamer:
“Attribute it to whatever phenomena you want — the potheads stayed away, the groupies weren’t interested, R***dGate ‘08 — but Tropic Thunder opened softer than planned on Wednesday. Ben Stiller’s Hollywood satire pulled in around $7.5 million, prompting observers to downgrade their weekend estimates that should nevertheless keep the film in first place above Star Wars: The Clone Wars and The Dark Knight this weekend. The turnout looked that much worse when compared to that of Pineapple Express, which drew more than $12 million last Wednesday — the best midweek, R-rated comedy opening in ages.”
Hopefully that means we’re making a difference!
August 15th, 2008 at 10:27 am
As far as the Los Angeles Times piece goes, that writer is WRONG about the NY Times review. Yes, the critic said that the bigger target was Hollywood stars and their egos, but she also notes that the infamous scene is marred by (direct quote) “a grindingly unfunny repetition of the word retard.” Maybe the writer should check his sources a little more closely!
August 15th, 2008 at 6:30 am
Mr. Flanigan’s piece “Disabilities Just Aren’t Funny” was appropriately written as an op- ed opinion essay. This Tropic Thunder debate is about our society and attitudes of casual disrespect to disabled people, not about some actor who thinks he can write or direct comedy. I’d like to see more commentary from people who are not Hollywood insiders or critics. Film critics will not bite the hand that feeds them.