An unkind cut: Why KatieThorpe should not have a hysterectomy
October 16th, 2007Should the mother of Katie Thorpe, a teenager with cerebral palsy, be able to demand a hysterectomy for her? Kate Ansell, who also has CP, says such a move should not be contemplated.
from the (UK) Independent
… Alison Thorpe might be right. Periods could be a trial for her daughter. But it’s possible that they won’t. I don’t believe she is wrong to suggest a hysterectomy, but I’m perplexed as to why it’s being considered before Katie’s periods have started, before anyone knows how they affect her, before other, less invasive methods of management have been tried.
When Katie’s periods start – an occasion which may yet become a national event if current speculation continues – her family and doctors will be able to observe the impact they have. Any decision made before that point will be nothing more than guesswork.


